Why “Fighting” for Your Kids May Not Be the Best Approach in Custody Disputes

When parents face divorce or custody battles, it’s natural to want to “fight for your kids.” It’s understandable because your children are the most important thing in your life and you don’t want to feel like you didn’t do everything that you could to protect them and be with them.

The truth is, however, that fighting isn’t always the best way to protect your children. Exposure to conflict, particularly prolonged conflict with the other parent, can harm your kids more than it helps. Standing up for your rights and your child’s well-being doesn’t have to mean constant confrontation. In this article, we’ll explore why fighting can be damaging, how stress affects children in high-conflict custody disputes, and healthier ways to advocate for your child.


The Difference Between Fighting and Advocating

There’s an important distinction between fighting and advocating for your children. Fighting often means reacting to every slight, retaliating against the other parent, or treating every disagreement as a battle. This approach creates a hostile environment where your child becomes caught in the middle.

By contrast, advocating for your kids means standing firm in your values, presenting your case clearly, and working toward outcomes that genuinely serve your child’s best interests. It’s less about “winning” and more about protecting their emotional and physical well-being.


How Conflict Impacts Children

As parents, we want to shield our kids from harm, but when custody and parenting time disputes turn combative, children often bear the brunt of the stress. Here’s how:

1. Emotional Stress

When parents fight, children feel it. Their hearts race, their bodies tense, and their minds become overwhelmed. They may feel caught between parents, unsure where their loyalty should lie, and some even blame themselves for the conflict.

2. Modeling Negative Behavior

Children learn by observing. If they see parents constantly fighting, they may grow up believing conflict resolution means confrontation. Instead of learning cooperation, compromise, and empathy, they absorb the lesson that battles are normal in relationships.

3. Long-Term Impact of Toxic Stress

Short-term stress can build resilience in children when loving adults provide support. But chronic stress, especially in the form of ongoing custody battles, can lead to toxic stress. This affects brain development, memory, emotional regulation, and can increase risks of anxiety, depression, and health problems into adulthood.


Why Fighting Feeds Toxic Stress

When children are exposed to relentless disputes, their bodies activate the “fight or flight” response over and over again. While occasional stress is manageable, being stuck in a heightened state of fear and anxiety can cause lasting damage. That’s why “fighting for your kids” in the sense of constant battles may do more harm than good.


Healthier Alternatives to Fighting

So, if fighting isn’t the answer, what can parents do instead?

1. Prioritize Collaboration

Choose approaches that minimize conflict, such as mediation, negotiation, or co-parenting counseling. These methods focus on solutions rather than arguments and often lead to better long-term outcomes for families.

2. Shield Your Children

Keep heated discussions and legal details away from your kids. Let them know both parents love them, and reassure them they’re not to blame for adult conflicts.

3. Model Cooperation

Show your children what healthy conflict resolution looks like. Demonstrate empathy, active listening, and compromise. By modeling cooperation, you give them tools to build healthier relationships in the future.

4. Respect the Opposing Position

When you’re in the midst of conflict, it can be very easy to become entrenched in what you want or believe. In doing so, you can easily shut out the opinion or viewpoint of the person on the other side. Closing your mind to an alternative point of view also closes your mind to concerns or ideas that might be beneficial to your and your children. You don’t have to necessarily agree with what the other person is saying, but don’t become so blinded by your conflict that you close yourself off to ideas and resolutions that may actually be helpful.


Choosing Advocacy Over Battle

At the heart of custody and family law disputes, every parent wants what’s best for their children. But remember: fighting doesn’t always equal caring. Standing up for your kids sometimes means stepping back from unnecessary battles and focusing on the bigger picture—their health, growth, and happiness.

By prioritizing collaboration, shielding children from conflict, and modeling positive behaviors, you set the foundation for your child to thrive despite the challenges of divorce or separation.


Fighting for your kids may feel like the natural response in a custody battle, but relentless conflict can take a devastating toll on children. Instead of equating fighting with love, choose advocacy, cooperation, and compassion. These strategies not only protect your child’s well-being but also create healthier co-parenting dynamics.

If you’re navigating a custody case or family law dispute, working with an experienced Oregon family law attorney can help you stand up for your rights without putting your child in the middle of constant conflict.